Mocap is grey
Category: Pesticides | Date: Apr 22 2009 | By: Martin Odino
During the meeting between FMC and Wildlifedirect together with involved conservationists on Furadan poisoning issues, a number of disturbing issues arose from what I will regard as normal defending of your own from the way FMC talked highly of Furadan.
I saw dismay in my colleagues faces when one FMC representative proclaimed that we needed to look out for purple granules around the mouth and in the vicinity if we wanted to have a basis of implicating furadan as the possible cause of death of an animal suspected to have been poisoned, and that…. Mocap is physically similar to Furadan. I recall someone asking innocently, “Is it also purple?” and the answer was a sure YES! Further, that there was a possibility of Furadan containers being re-packed with non-furadan but similar looking granules, the likes of Mocap resulting to false implication of furadan as the culprit poison.
Of course there were many other attempts by the FMC persons to protect their product among them that Furadan is just a name used to define any deadly poisonous pesticide. But what has been tormenting me much as I was doubtful of FMC’s narration is the possibility that I may have missed out on a chemical, especially Mocap and thought it was Furadan being used in some poisoning cases. So today I set out to buy the chemical which is turning out the big time replacement for Furadan for agricultural uses.

Above is the 200 grammes package of Mocap. The cost prize for the pack is USD2.5 but after bargaining, I bought it at USD2.25.

I opened the container and was met by a repulsive pungent whiff. I hope this characteristic makes it difficult to use the pesticide to poison wildlife. I was right to doubt the colour dictated to us by the FMC guys. Surely the granules look grey! the least you can come to link grey with purple is to say grey is a shade of purple, may be?


I even tried dissolving Mocap granules in water just incase it would yield a purple solution. From my basic chemistry, I know that the likes of copper sulphate change from white crystals to give a blue-coloured solution. I think what you are seeing above is a misty suspension, more grey than purple.

This is now purple and I witnessed its preparation, watching a poacher add water on to furadan granules then stir thoroughly.
Surely, Furadan is purple and Mocap is grey!
Tags: FMC, furadan, Mocap, poisoning, Wildlife, Wildlifedirect



3 Responses to “Mocap is grey”
Masumi, on 23 Apr 2009
Good going Martin. I think we are being naive if we take everything FMC said to us in the meeting at face value. There is definitely a distinct colour difference. Perhaps we should try and do some kind of a preliminary test using both pesticides to see which would be most effective for poison. Of course it would have to be some sort of ethical experiment anyway.
Dana-Phoenix Arizona, on 23 Apr 2009
Why don’t we do the experiment on the folks at FMC? Just kidding. I am very disappointed in FMC - sounds like they are not that willing to work with those that want this product banned. Wny don’t they kick in some money for the analysis!
Martin, on 23 Apr 2009
Hi Masumi & Dana. Thanks for your comments.
Masumi, I get so miserable and frustrated at times that I cannot resist the thought of laboratory animal toxicity testing. From the outrageous killing of biodiversity that we have witnessed, I cannot but wonder if FMC did enough evaluation on the toxicity of Furadan on wildlife. Sadly,so many have been poisoned and continue to be poisoned, maybe we should leave comparative animal toxicity testing of furadan versus mocap as a last resort.However, mocap has a repulsive pungent smell which I believe would repel wildlife if it was used for poisoning. I also wish I knew and I hope it does taste repulsively. Furadan on the other hand has no smell hence animals would not detect it in food bait.
Dana, FMC should surely contribute towards analysis charges. Surely, it means if the samples test negative then they have reason to quickly reverse furadan’s withdrawal. We can therefore only quietly deduce that the samples are highly likely to test positive. Why assist my adversary to push the dagger deeper after he has already knifed me?
Trackback URI | Comments RSS
Leave a Reply